NHL · Thursday, November 5, 2026 at 7:10 PM ET · Final: this preview was written before the game

Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets prediction: Casey DeSmith gets the Stars' crease as Columbus rides a 7-2 rout

Dallas brings the NHL's stingiest shot suppression to Nationwide Arena, but a backup goalie and an unsettled Heiskanen give the Blue Jackets an opening.

The line
LineDallas Stars -130 (puck line -1.5)
Total (over/under)5.5

Consensus of US sportsbooks, updated Nov 5, 6:05 PM ET.

Quick take
  • Expect a low-event game: Dallas allows few shots and draws the fewest power plays, so Columbus needs its finishers to cash scarce chances.
  • Goaltending decides it: DeSmith, expected over Oettinger, owns an 88.8% save rate; Columbus hasn't settled on Greaves or Talbot.
  • Dallas is a -128 road favorite with the total at 5.5, unmoved since our feed first saw the game; Stars games are 11-4 to the under.

Dallas turns to its backup

The Stars have won two straight and want a third, but they are taking a different goalie into Columbus. Casey DeSmith is expected to start, though the team hasn't confirmed it, giving Jake Oettinger a night off after he allowed five goals on 25 Capitals shots Tuesday. Dallas isn't on a back-to-back, so this reads as a rest call rather than a schedule one.

The gap between the two is real. Oettinger has carried the load, starting 12 of 15 games with a 90.9% save rate and a 1.91 goals-against average. DeSmith sits at 88.8% and 2.94 in three appearances, a small sample but not a reassuring one.

The blue line is unsettled too. Miro Heiskanen left Tuesday's win after one second-period shift with an upper-body injury and is day-to-day. Coach Glen Gulutzan said Wednesday he likely wouldn't play, then on Thursday stopped short of ruling him out. Losing a defenseman who logs 24.9 minutes a night would push Thomas Harley into a bigger role, likely including the top power play.

Special teams tilt to Dallas

Both units favor the visitors. The Stars kill 90.0% of opponents' power plays, 2nd in the league, while Columbus converts just 17.1% of its chances (power-play goals per opportunity), 24th. Flip it around and the Blue Jackets' penalty kill ranks 24th at 72.5%, against a Dallas power play that sits 11th.

The catch is volume. Dallas draws only 2.27 power plays a game, last in the NHL, and Columbus ranks 28th in the same category. Neither team lives on the man advantage, so the edge may show up once, if at all.

Columbus has to make shots count

Dallas is built to choke games. The Stars allow 22.5 shots a game, 2nd in the league, and 2.33 goals, 3rd. Columbus generates 25.5 shots, 26th, so it can't count on volume.

That puts the weight on finishers. Kent Johnson has seven goals on 26 shots, and Charlie Coyle tied his career high with four points, two of them goals, in Tuesday's 7-2 rout of Colorado. Coyle's third line, with Cole Sillinger and Mathieu Olivier, drew Colorado's top line in that game, and a similar job against Dallas' best forwards looms. Zach Werenski drives the offense from the back end with 12 assists and no goals.

The Stars' scoring runs through Mikko Rantanen and Jason Robertson, who each have 18 points. Rantanen is converting 27.6% of his shots, a pace few sustain, while Robertson leads the team with 49 shots. Columbus won both meetings last season, but Dallas took the first one this year 3-1 on Oct. 31, and this is the teams' final meeting of the season.

Who's in the Columbus net

The Blue Jackets haven't named a starter. Jet Greaves is listed as the probable, and Cam Talbot made 27 saves in Tuesday's win. With Buffalo on Friday, the two will split the back-to-back in some order.

Talbot has been the steadier option at 90.0%, while Greaves sits at 88.3% with a 3.11 goals-against average. Either way, Columbus is 5-3-0 at home against a Dallas team that is 4-1-1 on the road.

What the market says

Dallas is a -128 favorite, with Columbus at +107 and the total at 5.5. Neither the puck line nor the total has moved since our feed first saw the game, so the DeSmith news hasn't shifted anything.

The total bears watching. Stars games have gone under 11 times in 15, a product of that shot suppression, while Columbus sits 6-7 to the over. A backup in the Dallas net is the main argument against that trend.

  • Whether Heiskanen dresses at warmups
  • Which Columbus goalie starts, with Buffalo up Friday
  • Coyle's line against Dallas' top forwards

Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets line movement and odds

Line movement (to the start): Dallas Stars -1.5, unchanged since it opened; the total has stayed at 5.5. Consensus of the regulated US sportsbooks, first seen Nov 4, 11:08 AM ET.

Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets odds at every sportsbook
BookStars MLJackets MLStars spreadTotal
BetMGM-130+110-1.5 (+190)o5.5 (-120)
DraftKings-125+105-1.5 (+195)o5.5 (-122)
ESPN BET-130+110-1.5 (+200)o5.5 (-125)
Fanatics-130+110-1.5 (+190)o5.5 (-125)
FanDuel-126+105-1.5 (+194)o5.5 (-120)
Hard Rock Bet-140+110-1.5 (+180)o5.5 (-115)
Caesars-127+108-1.5 (+195)o5.5 (-117)

Prices as of Nov 5, 7:08 PM ET; they move, so check your sportsbook before betting.

Key players

  • Casey DeSmith (Dallas Stars): Has an 88.8% save rate and 2.94 goals-against average in three games this season.
  • Mikko Rantanen (Dallas Stars): Has 18 points this season, converting 27.6% of his shots.
  • Jason Robertson (Dallas Stars): Matches Rantanen with 18 points and leads Dallas with 49 shots this season.
  • Miro Heiskanen (Dallas Stars): Logs 24.9 minutes a game with 11 points this season, but his status for Thursday is unsettled.
  • Charlie Coyle (Columbus Blue Jackets): Leads Columbus with 13 points this season and had four in Tuesday's win.
  • Kent Johnson (Columbus Blue Jackets): Has seven goals this season on a 26.9% shooting rate.
  • Zach Werenski (Columbus Blue Jackets): Plays 28.5 minutes a game with 12 assists this season.
  • Jet Greaves (Columbus Blue Jackets): Sits at 88.3% this season, though Columbus hasn't confirmed its starter.

Numbers that matter

Dallas shots allowed22.52nd in the NHL, squeezing a Columbus attack that ranks 26th in shots.
Dallas penalty kill90.0%2nd in the league against a Columbus power play ranked 24th.
DeSmith save rate88.8%Well below Oettinger's 90.9%, in a three-game sample.
Stars over/under record4-11Dallas games have mostly stayed under, with the total at 5.5 tonight.
Dallas moneyline-128The Stars are road favorites, with Columbus at +107.

Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets: quick answers

What is the over/under for Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets?

The total is 5.5 goals.

When is Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets?

Thursday, November 5, 2026 at 7:10 PM ET.

Has the line moved for Dallas Stars vs Columbus Blue Jackets?

No: Dallas Stars has stayed at -1.5, and the total is still 5.5 (consensus of the regulated US sportsbooks since we first saw the game).

More on Dallas Stars and Columbus Blue Jackets. Updated Nov 5, 7:08 PM ET. Lines move; check your sportsbook before betting. 21+. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

More NHL previews for Thu, Nov 5, 2026

All NHL predictions and picks · How we write previews